- cross-posted to:
- [email protected]
- cross-posted to:
- [email protected]
The harm of religion is historically evident whereas the presence or absence of gods is not. Ultimately, the continued existence of religion is predicated on the indoctrination of children and suppression of rational thought. Therefore I am against religion but not necessarily against the idea of gods. For all we know gods are computer scientists and we are in their video game.
I am begging you to first learn historical materialism about the development of religions across the globe, what roles other than “indoctrination” they have played socially, and how capitalism co-opted religion and has hollowed it out as it does with everything. A lot of your critique is about the powerful utilizing societal tools in the language of religion to exploit followers. Second, please for the love of any god you choose read some actual scholars of religion or philosophy of religion. it isn’t enough to build strawmen with Hitchens and Harris and South Park. if your thesis is to consider antireligion as a viable alternative to religion, you need to engage with actual scholars, actual lived experiences of the religions and irreligious in the midst of capitalism, and the historical repercussions of labour history in and around religious movements.
education is never objective, it is never apolitical, and systematic education does not unlock human potential under capitalism, it signals social credentials to the bourgeois that you can move in that world and are most likely going to uphold those mores.
you’ve got a good start with putting your figure on a problem, that religion has been a tool used to exploit peoples for centuries and keep them in the lower classes through education, control over bodies, etc. keep going, just interact with more marxism and scholars in the field to dig further.
I didn’t say antireligion should be the alternative to religion, ideally neither exists. Thanks for your input though. However, I am not trying to put forth essays of academic rigour. My main objective is to get people to think and talk, more often than not about topics that are often times avoided. That being said, I’m open to any source you send my way; ideally somewhat terse to get me started. No time to go delving into a dense book.
Were you not around for ~2010 and the entire Nu Atheist “movement”?
Listen to this on a walk or something: https://librivox.org/socialism-utopian-and-scientific-by-friedrich-engels/