The key thing to remember is that a one day blackout won’t have an effect on the corporations. What it will do is get more people comfortable with taking action. If you can go one day without buying from Amazon, two days isn’t much more, and then a week, and then a month. The idea is to ratchet up the action.
Just like how fascism has a progression to slowly “boil the frog,” collective societal action does, too. This isn’t an end but a beginning.
I don’t think it’s much of a problem. People taking part want to do something to combat Trump and Elon, but many don’t know how. And let’s face it, it’s kinda scary to try to go up against powerful people. This is an easy, low-threat way to get started. It’s for Jim and Jane down the street who want to do something but don’t know what and are afraid of going all in right now.
So, if they boycott for just a day as a symbol, they see it’s not so bad. Hell, they may even make it two or three just on their own. Then the next call to blackout comes a month later, but this time it’s for a week. Easy. Now, this time, they find alternative local businesses who align with their positions to get “emergency” supplies from. Then the next call comes for a month’s blackout, and they realize that they haven’t been buying from the big companies at all, so that’s easy.
But, they still feel like they aren’t doing enough. Isn’t fighting supposed to be harder? So, they decide to attend a small protest. Then a bigger protest. Suddenly, Jim and Jane realize that they are going to city hall meetings, protests, etc., which they never thought they’d get involved in. And it started with just taking a day off from buying things.
Obviously, this won’t happen for everyone where they get hyper-involved. For most, it’ll probably just be doing the economic blackouts for however long at a time or just finding alternate places to do business so they feel like they’re helping. And you know what, that’s fine. If people turn away from the big businesses, even just 20%, that will start to show up.
Getting people to take part in actions that have no effect on their target can eventually make them feel that all such actions are pointless, though.
It can always be spun as a symbolic statement, but giving it the appearance of an economic boycott leads to confusion about how effective boycotts actually work.
The key thing to remember is that a one day blackout won’t have an effect on the corporations. What it will do is get more people comfortable with taking action. If you can go one day without buying from Amazon, two days isn’t much more, and then a week, and then a month. The idea is to ratchet up the action.
Just like how fascism has a progression to slowly “boil the frog,” collective societal action does, too. This isn’t an end but a beginning.
The problem with this approach is that the frog knows you are trying to boil it.
I don’t think it’s much of a problem. People taking part want to do something to combat Trump and Elon, but many don’t know how. And let’s face it, it’s kinda scary to try to go up against powerful people. This is an easy, low-threat way to get started. It’s for Jim and Jane down the street who want to do something but don’t know what and are afraid of going all in right now.
So, if they boycott for just a day as a symbol, they see it’s not so bad. Hell, they may even make it two or three just on their own. Then the next call to blackout comes a month later, but this time it’s for a week. Easy. Now, this time, they find alternative local businesses who align with their positions to get “emergency” supplies from. Then the next call comes for a month’s blackout, and they realize that they haven’t been buying from the big companies at all, so that’s easy.
But, they still feel like they aren’t doing enough. Isn’t fighting supposed to be harder? So, they decide to attend a small protest. Then a bigger protest. Suddenly, Jim and Jane realize that they are going to city hall meetings, protests, etc., which they never thought they’d get involved in. And it started with just taking a day off from buying things.
Obviously, this won’t happen for everyone where they get hyper-involved. For most, it’ll probably just be doing the economic blackouts for however long at a time or just finding alternate places to do business so they feel like they’re helping. And you know what, that’s fine. If people turn away from the big businesses, even just 20%, that will start to show up.
Then you make jumping out of the pot the worse option
Getting people to take part in actions that have no effect on their target can eventually make them feel that all such actions are pointless, though.
It can always be spun as a symbolic statement, but giving it the appearance of an economic boycott leads to confusion about how effective boycotts actually work.