I’m looking for a special forever home for Elmo and Gumby, a bonded pair of 3.5-year-old spayed cats who came from a hoarding situation. I want to be very upfront: they are extremely shy cats and will need a patient adopter who understands that trust may come slowly.

About them:

Bonded pair — they must stay together

Spayed, around 3.5 years old

Indoor cats

Very shy / fearful at first and likely will hide while adjusting

Gentle, sweet temperaments — never aggressive

Their personalities:

Gumby is the braver/more outgoing one. Once comfortable, she enjoys pets and scratches.

Elmo is much more timid. At this time, she does not want to be touched and needs her boundaries respected.

These are not “instant lap cats.” They need someone compassionate who can let them move at their own pace, provide a calm environment, and celebrate small steps. They may be a great fit for someone experienced with shy cats or who simply has the patience to let animals unfold in their own time.

Why rehoming:

They are not doing well with my resident cat, and I believe they would thrive in a quieter home where they can feel secure.

Located in Brooklyn / NYC area. Happy to answer questions, share photos/videos, and talk honestly about their needs so it’s the right match.

Please message me if interested or share with anyone who may be the right person ❤️