I recently had FTTP installed (UK - YouFibre) which came with its own router connected to the newly installed ONT.

Previously I was on Virgin Media, using their router on modem-only mode and connected to my Google Nest Wifi.

Despite the engineer telling me I had to go through the supplied YouFibre router first, on a whim I switched the Google wifi from the Virgin router directly into the Ethernet port on the ONT. I was pleasantly surprised to find it worked immediately without any additional configuration.

This is great - one less device plugged in etc. but I wonder if there is anything I should be aware of in doing this?

Am I just being paranoid?

  • gkhouzam@alien.topBEnglish
    1·
    10 months ago

    The ONT gives out an Ethernet signal. If the Google WiFi gets the IP address you are good. The one thing that the ISP can say is that you are not supported if you have an issue because it’s not connected to their router. If that’s the case swap out routers when you have issues.

    I’ve been running Google WiFi straight to my ONT for years.

  • REF_YOU_SUCK@alien.topBEnglish
    1·
    10 months ago

    Had a FiOS tech out to my home a few weeks ago because I was having some signal issues with the FiOS TV.

    I currently had my old FiOS router sitting behind my NetGear DDWRT router, which was plugged directly into the ETH port on the ONT.

    Tech replaced the ONT and cleaned up some CoAx cabling, then told me that the FiOS router HAD to be connected to the ONT first or the cable wouldnt work.

    he said this, despite the fact that it was working previously for years the way I had it set up.

    I didn’t feel like arguing with the guy so as soon as he left I swtiched it back and its working fine.

    Those techs that go out to homes don’t really have a higher understanding of whats going on. they install the cable and set it up as the telco tells them to.

    • captain-carrot@alien.topOPBEnglish
      1·
      10 months ago

      To be fair they will be trained to follow a standard setup and may not know any better - easier just to say “This is the thing that I know works” after all.

      When I saw the ONT had an ethernet port I suspected it might be as simple as plugging in despite what he said!

    • Stormhunter6@alien.topBEnglish
      1·
      10 months ago

      In their defense, it is likely because most of their base is barely tech literate at best, and if the hardware is their own, they can maintain and update it regularly, lest they end up with a customer keep a router that hasn’t been updated in years.

      My buddy was using a WRT54G model router for their internet, keep in mind the hardware was almost 10 years old by this point. They were wondering why their internet was craptastic aside from a single wired connection. It wasn’t until I visited them that I rebooted their router and the Wifi/LAN miraculously started working normally for the first time in months, and then got them to buy something up to date. Keep in mind this is a person who is a programmer with a masters in mechanical engineering.

  • OnlyTilt@alien.topBEnglish
    1·
    10 months ago

    In Canada there were a few good years when Telus gave us fiber internet through a Nokia GPON ONT SFP+ module, which we could plug directly into a SFP+ router and ignore all of the ISP equipment, thoses were the days, now they moved to XGS-PON and we have to user their network hub since the XGS-PON module doesnt have onboard registration hardware :(

  • OwnubadJr@alien.topBEnglish
    1·
    10 months ago

    Nah you’ll be fine. For my ISP I just had to set a VLAN 1000 and that got me going.