Considering Gram is dealing overwhelmingly slash damage as base I thought Buzz Kill’s +120% slash damage would be a slam dunk on it, yet none of the popular builds use that mod.

Does this have something to do with how damage is calculated that I’m missing or are physical damage increase mods just always a bad idea?

  • tiresieas@dormi.zone
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    10
    ·
    1 year ago

    Without getting super into it, Physical mods are essentially a scam of a mod.

    • They do not affect your base damage, so they don’t also improve your elemental mods.

    • The effective damage increase is only a fraction based on the baseline ratio: using Buzz Saw on Gram Prime as an example, a +120% slash on a weapon with 75% slash results in a total +90% damage.

    • The real nail in the coffin is that the bleed status does not scale with slash damage, it only scales with base damage, base damage mods (like Pressure Point or Condition Overload), and double dips with faction mods (turning a normal +30% Bane into a 1.66x multiplier, and a primed Bane with +55% into a 2.4x multiplier), while also being affected by other damage multipliers (like crits, headshots, etc).

    There are legitimate uses for physical mods, but for regular melee use, the opportunity cost of using them is high, when you could slot in other things to pump up your damage output higher. A regular Bane will almost reach the same damage output as Buzz Saw on Gram Prime (of course vs the specific enemy), while also increasing your Slash proc damage further.

    Legitimate uses include bumping up a slash ratio to being above 50% for dismemberment (to produce more Desecrate targets); for certain weapons (eg Shaku is full Impact) and stat stick abilities (Landslide is full Impact) that only deal 100% physical damage to get an actually effective +120% damage buff; for certain stat stick abilities (eg Whipclaw) that don’t benefit from something better like banes, and can fish for more slash procs with it.

  • neooffs@dormi.zone
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    7
    ·
    1 year ago

    from what I know slash mods don’t increase the damage of slash procs. maybe that’s why

  • Dystopia@dormi.zone
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    5
    ·
    1 year ago

    If this is for a Heavy Attack build, you might find that weapons with forced slash procs on heavy attack feel a lot more consistent like Scythes/2-handed Nikanas. The other benefit of relying on forced slash procs is that you don’t need to worry about status chance/slash weighting. (not all heavy attacks have forced slash)

    If this is for a Quick Attack build, then you probably care about status chance and slash weighting because you will be hitting enemies multiple times, and not all stances/combos have a forced slash proc.

    Heavy blades only seem to have a forced slash on a ground finisher, but its slash weighting is high enough that you probably don’t need Jagged Edge anyways. (Carnis Mandible might be better for + status chance, or Weeping Wounds for 12x combo builds)

    The last reason is that +Slash mods only increase the upfront damage on the initial hit but do not effect the value of the slash ticks. I think the only mods that effect the tick damage are base damage mods like Pressure Point/Condition Overload, Crit Chance + Damage Mods, and Banes.

  • Spoke0thedevil@lemm.ee
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    1 year ago

    Usually because unless you are trying to get a certain status proc, physical damage mods kinda suck. Since a slash mod will adjust according to the BASE SLASH damage of the weapon, while elemental mods damage increase is based on all of the base damage of the weapon.

  • misericordiae@kbin.social
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    edit-2
    1 year ago

    In addition to what neooffs said, it looks like a fully upgraded Buzz Kill (120% slash) increases flat damage (ignoring procs) on Gram Prime as much as a fully upgraded (non primed) Fever Strike (90% toxin) for the same cost. So if you only have one flex slot, going toxin instead is 1) an extra status type for Condition Overload and 2) upgradable to a Primed Fever Strike (165% toxin) for more damage if you’ve got the mod and capacity. If you have more than one flex slot, I guess it depends on the goals of your build and the statuses you already have access to on your loadout, but other mods might still be more beneficial.

    From my (maybe questionable) understanding, slash mods have some value when:

    1. you’re low on capacity and the base slash weighting is high enough, a Jagged Edge (90% slash) or Carnis Mandible (90/60) (or non-melee equivalents) adds more flat damage than a 60/60 or equivalent capacity 90% elemental mod. Again, I suspect YMMV depending on statuses in your loadout, but I might be wrong.
    2. you’re trying to mess with the IPS weighting for more chance of slash damage over puncture/impact, for Desecrate dismemberment.
    3. you’re trying to mess with general proc weighting for a better chance of slash procs over other procs (this is the area I’m fuzziest on, maybe someone else can explain if/when you’d want to do this).
    • Kaldo@kbin.socialOP
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      1 year ago

      I see, so it’s mostly that even 90% elemental mods are bad value in today’s meta, I see most often people skipping even serration/point blank I guess due to galvanized mods. Thanks for clarifying!

      • misericordiae@kbin.social
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        3
        ·
        1 year ago

        Glad to help! Hopefully I haven’t misspoken–I’m not an expert modder by any means.

        I wouldn’t say 90% elemental mods are bad value–they have their place bulking out damage on very low status chance weapons or ones modded exclusively for crit. They’re also good if you want to beef up a status when you’ve already slotted the 60/60 version. Even IPS mods aren’t bad, they’re just very niche (some more than others… lookin’ at you, puncture).

        Also, the reason Serration/Point Blank get left off is due to their being replaced by weapon arcanes like Primary/Secondary Merciless. The diminishing returns of putting more than one +damage source on a weapon are too high to justify having both (plus you get an extra mod slot to play with).

  • b14700@lemm.ee
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    1 year ago

    because it already does slash procs , damage of slash procs is all that matters for that build and increasing slash damage does not increase slash proc damage , just the likelihood of applying a slash proc