Prinz1989 [he/him]

Strong Dark Knight rises vibes. Getting rid of rich people and police means also getting nuked. The ony thing keeping us from nuking ourselves is that it would destroy capital.

Had the GDR given everyone the equivalent of a Volkswagen (as an example) I believe they would have succeeded, but a Trabant you wait a decade for? And the Volkswagen was not for “some”. Very few German workers would not be able to afford one. You have to look at the standard of average people to learn something about the viability of a society. A socialist society should avoid big differences I agree, but not be overall worse materially than capitalism (this includes spare time which capitalism hardly provides). And the people in eastern Germany were not happy about having cars at all, because they could see and often had family in the west living a much better life. Just because the covid response of my country could be worse I’m still jelous of China because they show very clearly that it could be much better.

For western workers “real socialism” looked poor and restrictive and utterly unapealing.

All of this raises the question of what socialist countries can do in the future to prevent reactionary propaganda from taking hold.

Have bananas. Seriously the more productive system will win in the end. The ecological question makes a steady rise in consumerism unfeasable and undisirable. A more productive society might give more spare time instead of treats and save the enviroment. However people in the east had less treats just as much work and were horrible to the enviroment as well. Stuff like inequality don’t mean anything. A west German worker might have a Volkswagen, his boss a BMW and his boss a Porsche, all of those are much better than a Trabant so people accepted it. Unemployment existed in the west for a few, the average worker would never assume to be one of the unemployed. The West saw massive immigation to help with worker shortages even. Capitalism is full of contradictions. If your socialism isn’t more productive than that, there is something wrong with it.

“The Lives of Others” is a German Stasi drama in which the Stasi tries to prevent the publishing of an article about rising suicide rates in the GDR. The implication is that these rising rates imply the failure of the GDR system. The film was produced as a general statemant against mass survaillance, but also an outright condemnation of the security apperatus of the GDR and the whole system. People rather kill themselves instead of continung to exist within the system. That it was made just before the manning/snowden leaks and suiciderates in the west starting to take off is really :marx-ok:

Every society has neccessary labour that just needs to be done. A planned economy would not be like:

Shure follow your dream just let a comrade toil in the factory in your place. Wait, why do we have 1.000.000 Zootopia fan fics but no bread?

But cancelling all the bullshit jobs , reducing the most enviromentally destructive forms of consumption like replacing cars with bikes and mass transit and planning cities so that everything you need is decently close would free up so much time. It is absolutly realistic to

• spend 6h a day for two days a week in your office/service job
• 6h on one day in your production job with lots of movement because health is important
• one day at a form of school university to educate and improve yourself
• have three days for yourself to do whatever you like

Like this would be possible today!

trotskyist is a nebulous concept of some kind of sinister group of bad people who do bad things, and if anything bad happens, well, what do you know, looks like they were to blame.

Stalin shouting from the grave: NO THAT WAS MY IDEA, CPAITALIST PIGS!