

I don’t understand how anyone thinks any part of this is going to work out.
- The vast majority of machines online are fully automated, how do you validate the age of an automated account? If automated accounts are allowed without verification, how can you possibly tell the difference between them and an actual person?
- How do you handle old and foreign software? Are they going to start prosecuting individual people for running non-compliant software? Can’t afford to update your old phone? Well now you’re a criminal.
- Validating age requires private information to identify who you are. They have completely put the security of this information on each individual OS. Expect this info to be leaked.
This will never keep someone from viewing something if they really want to. All it will do is open up individuals to prosecution if they want to use any device anonymously.












The email sounds like a college student participating in a sociology study for class and asking the professor for clarification. This is exactly the kind of thing that I’d expect to ask about gender along with a bunch of other personal information. The goal being to see if any patterns in the responses.
Sociology in general does have the problem that categories are important and helpful to spotting patterns, but people are very difficult to categorize. People just don’t fit cleanly into categories