• 0 Posts
  • 104 Comments
Joined 4 years ago
cake
Cake day: March 25th, 2022

help-circle


  • poo_22@lemmygrad.mltoMemes@lemmygrad.mlBig Mad
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    2
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    6 months ago

    the american left are idealists and utopians at best

    Seriously. Take the issue of immigration. If you say that maybe we shouldn’t have open borders as a first order of business they will scream “communism is when no borders” but they ignore the fact that there may be issues with opening borders fully given current conditions. And so the discussion stops completely and both sides are left frustrated.



  • poo_22@lemmygrad.mltoMemes@lemmygrad.mlBig Mad
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    6 months ago

    My understanding of Marx is that economic conditions must change first, then society adapts to it. By conditions here I mean things like climate, war, famine, and technological progress. I don’t think people reading is going to change anything.

    By now everyone knows that America is committing a genocide in gaza, but Americans keep going to work. If something like genocide can’t change the course of society, how am I supposed to believe that a few people reading theory will change anything?

    Theory can be applied once people are forced to change. So it definitely has it’s place.

    If I’m actually wrong please direct me to what Marx or Lenin said about theory changing material conditions.





  • Like they will run circles around being wrong and then pat themselves on the back and call me a dumb Russian troll or something.

    Liberals do this, they won’t listen to you anyways. They will laugh at you because what you’re saying is against the ideas of the ruling class, which to them is the obvious dominant way of thinking in society.

    You have to very calmly and succinctly utterly destroy every part of their argument, call them out on shifting goalposts and then, and this is the key part, they will try to lie to support their argument. If you catch them lying without getting mad you will have the upper hand.

    One shortcut can be catching them being racist. Libs are racist, more so than right wingers in the sense that right wingers want to be racist to hurt people’s feelings liberals don’t even acknowledge that some people are human, and if you catch them in this act of dehumanization (eg: I don’t hate the people, i just hate the government. Okay but why don’t their people hate the government. Because they’re all brainwashed. So you think their whole population is easily brainwashed and they need you to tell them the truth?) Sometimes that gets them to shut the fuck up and reflect a little bit.

    I don’t think this battle is worth it though, most of the time. Like you said it’s exhausting. These people don’t have any real friends anyway, have you noticed?

    You could also just attack them personally for being a fascist.



  • poo_22@lemmygrad.mltoMemes@lemmygrad.mlBig Mad
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    8 months ago

    I don’t know if this is an ultra leftist take or just a regular leftist take but I keep hearing how only changing material conditions will bring about social change in the US. But then why the heck are we even bothering to read theory and talk about it with people?

    Another take is that communists should be supporting countries that the west is most profiting from via imperialism, and help those countries fight back against imperialism, which would lead to changing conditions in the west. And like okay, I guess we can do that but not everyone can just go travel and be a professional revolutionary, so again, are communists in the states supposed to be doing something or patiently waiting?

    What’s your best take on this?









  • I heard once that car manufacturers can’t make cars without Chinese parts. They say they’re made in Europe or America but really they’re just assembled there.

    So idk what President Trump was thinking when he put over 100% tariffs on China but I’m glad it’s crashing the economy. Unfortunately economic decline in a real sense has to happen for social progress in America at this point. And I am cautiously optimistic that this is already working with the recent marches going on. Those marches need more coverage, and they need more organization of people during the march, so that people who who attend walk away with more than they came in with (even if it’s just a secure way of contacting their group so they can decide on further action). They also need a leadership structure.