Hi all. Noob question/s here. I want to be able to access my Immich server (docker) externally and maybe set up some others (e.g. Mealio). My understanding is that I need (should) use NGINX reverse proxy for this. My questions are:

  1. Do I need to set up NGINX on a VPS (or similar cloud based server) to send the queries to my home box?

  2. Do I need to purchase a domain (randomblahblah.xyz) to use as the main access route from outside my house?

Thanks a lot.

  • PriorProject@lemmy.worldEnglish
    14·
    1 year ago

    Do I need to set up NGINX on a VPS (or similar cloud based server) to send the queries to my home box?

    A proxy on a VPS is one way to do this, but not the only way and not necessarily the best one… depending on your goals.

    • You can also use port-forwarding and dyndns to just expose the port off your home-ip. If your ISP is sucky, this may not work though.
    • You can also use Cloudflare’s free tunneling product, which is basically a hosted proxy that acts like a super port-forward that bypasses sucky ISP restrictions.
    • If you want to access Immich yourself from your own devices but don’t need to make it available to (many) others on devices you don’t control, I like and use tailscale the best. The advantage of tailscale is that Immich remains on a private network, not directly scannable from the internet. If there’s a preauth exploit published and you don’t pay attention to update promptly, scanners WILL exploit your Immich instance with internet-exposed techniques… whereas tailscale allows you to access services that internet scanners cannot connect to, which is a nice safety net.

    Do I need to purchase a domain (randomblahblah.xyz) to use as the main access route from outside my house?

    Not for tailscale, and I don’t think for Cloudflare tunnel. Yes for a VPS proxy.

    I’ve run a VPS for a long while and use multiple techniques for different services.

    • Some services I run directly on the VPS because it’s simple and I want them to be truly publicly accessible.
    • Other services I run on a bigger server at home and proxy through the VPS because although I want them to be publicly accessible, they require more resources than my VPS has available. When I get around to installing Immich, there’s a decent chance it will go into this category.
    • Still other services, I run wherever and attach them to my tailnet. These I access myself on my own devices (or maybe invite a handful of trusted people into my tailnet), but aren’t visible to the public internet. If I decide not to use immich’s shared gallery features (and so don’t need it publicly accessible) or decide I don’t trust it security-wise… it will go here instead of the proxy-by-vps category.
    • fiddlestix@lemmy.worldOPEnglish
      3·
      1 year ago

      Thanks a lot. Tailscale is out, unfortunately. Because the server also runs Plex and I need to use it with Chromecast on remote access (it’s an old CC, so can’t add tailscale to it). Looking into Cloudflare and port forwarding. I’ve just signed up to NextDNS though, so don’t want to add another layer of DNS stuff to my mix.

      • PriorProject@lemmy.worldEnglish
        3·
        1 year ago

        Tailscale is out, unfortunately. Because the server also runs Plex and I need to use it with Chromecast on remote access…

        I rather suspect you already understand this, but for anyone following along… Tailscale can be combined with other networking techniques as well. So one could:

        • Access Plex from a Chromecast on your home network using your physical IP, and on your tailnet using the overlay IP.
        • Or one could have some services exposed publicly and others exposed on the tailnet. So Immich could be on the tailnet while Plex is exposed differently.

        It’s not an all or nothing proposition, but of course the more networking components you have the more complicated everything gets. If one can simplify, it’s often well worth doing so.

        Good luck, however you approach it.