That’s… not quite right. Did you get this from skimming Wikipedia? It’s true that the first TNG ep featuring Alexander had someone other than Bonsall play the role, that kid stopped acting almost immediately after. Bonsall played Alexander for the rest of TNG. They age up Alexander significantly for his return in DS9, so, yeah, needs a different actor. There’s a TNG ep where Alexander comes back from the future to try and correct what a shitty character they made, so that’s probably your “fourth” Alexander and I’m not sure where the fifth comes from.
Edit: Looked that one up. The “Fifth Alexander” is a technicality. Worf has a picture of him and Alexander as one of his personal effects that he brings with him onto DS9 and the person in that picture “playing” Alexander is uncredited, but makes no other appearance other than being in that photo.
Hey I’m actually baffled by your reply. You clearly didn’t know there were 5 actors who played Alexander, because if you did, you’d know they were mostly one offs, from a different series at a different age or, uh, a photograph. It’s like you saw my comment, decided to reply to it, searched “Star Trek Alexander actor” and read the headline of the first result, a Screen Rant article titled “Star Trek: All 5 Actors Who Played Worf’s Son, Alexander”, and decided “That’s enough info, I’m ready to reply to that comment.”
Clearly you didn’t read the article, otherwise you wouldn’t reply the way you did, because you’d know why there’s 5 Alexander’s and it wasn’t because the writers were trying to fix the issue.
I’m not mad or annoyed or anything, I’m just utterly baffled by how you use the internet.
I’m not mad or annoyed or anything, I’m just utterly baffled by how you use the internet.
Are you sure about that because this is the second time you’ve replied to me on this topic, clearly upset about something so trivial.
I knew there were two actors and saw the articles pointing out that they actually used 5 actors for the role when trying to google the name of the second actor who killed himself a several years back. Yes, I did read the article and saw that one was just in a photograph, which brings me back to my initial point of ‘who really gives a crap?’ My original comment was more of a joke than anything.
Star Trek has always struggled with child actors, but I think Bonsall was really just too young to handle the role. In part, I think the writers realized this and tried to cut him out, but this lead to the issue of making Worf look like a horrible father, so they bring him back and repeat.
He was a child so I can’t put any blame on Bonsall, but I truly think it was a serious mistake to cast him for that.
Brian Bonsall as Alexander in Star Trek The Next Generation.
The role was poorly thought out and written, that’s not his fault, but the kid always looked wildly uncomfortable in the loaf and couldn’t act at all.
They had 5 separate actors play the character so it seems like they were desperately trying to fix the issue.
That’s… not quite right. Did you get this from skimming Wikipedia? It’s true that the first TNG ep featuring Alexander had someone other than Bonsall play the role, that kid stopped acting almost immediately after. Bonsall played Alexander for the rest of TNG. They age up Alexander significantly for his return in DS9, so, yeah, needs a different actor. There’s a TNG ep where Alexander comes back from the future to try and correct what a shitty character they made, so that’s probably your “fourth” Alexander and I’m not sure where the fifth comes from.
Edit: Looked that one up. The “Fifth Alexander” is a technicality. Worf has a picture of him and Alexander as one of his personal effects that he brings with him onto DS9 and the person in that picture “playing” Alexander is uncredited, but makes no other appearance other than being in that photo.
Hey I’m actually baffled by your reply. You clearly didn’t know there were 5 actors who played Alexander, because if you did, you’d know they were mostly one offs, from a different series at a different age or, uh, a photograph. It’s like you saw my comment, decided to reply to it, searched “Star Trek Alexander actor” and read the headline of the first result, a Screen Rant article titled “Star Trek: All 5 Actors Who Played Worf’s Son, Alexander”, and decided “That’s enough info, I’m ready to reply to that comment.”
Clearly you didn’t read the article, otherwise you wouldn’t reply the way you did, because you’d know why there’s 5 Alexander’s and it wasn’t because the writers were trying to fix the issue.
I’m not mad or annoyed or anything, I’m just utterly baffled by how you use the internet.
Are you sure about that because this is the second time you’ve replied to me on this topic, clearly upset about something so trivial.
I knew there were two actors and saw the articles pointing out that they actually used 5 actors for the role when trying to google the name of the second actor who killed himself a several years back. Yes, I did read the article and saw that one was just in a photograph, which brings me back to my initial point of ‘who really gives a crap?’ My original comment was more of a joke than anything.
Everyone I see him I feel like he’s trying so hard to disappear. Just will it into existence.
Star Trek has always struggled with child actors, but I think Bonsall was really just too young to handle the role. In part, I think the writers realized this and tried to cut him out, but this lead to the issue of making Worf look like a horrible father, so they bring him back and repeat.
He was a child so I can’t put any blame on Bonsall, but I truly think it was a serious mistake to cast him for that.
Oh no, I feel so bad for him! It’s insanely hard for a kid to be amazing at acting. I hope the best for him!