The University of Florida campus group says the suspension over an off-campus post violated free speech
A dispute among student Republican groups in Florida over alleged antisemitic behavior is heading for a courtroom after a chapter at the state’s flagship university was suspended for an online post featuring two people giving Nazi salutes.
On Saturday, University of Florida (UF) blocked campus operations of the school’s College Republicans after the group’s state leadership said it had disbanded the chapter for engaging in “a pattern of conduct that violated its rules and values, including a recent antisemitic gesture”.
The chapter responded Monday by filing a free speech lawsuit against UF leadership, arguing that the action violated the constitutional first amendment rights of a member engaging in an off-campus activity.
Why is the university being sued? The group was disbanded by the state level college republican group. That should have resulted in the university cutting ties anyway.
These Republicans are Nazis. Nazis have a basic plank of calling for the death of groups of people based upon race, ethnicity, birth defects, and even world views (Communists, Atheists).
The university has every right to protect the other students at the university from genocidal maniacs. It’s not an issue of Tolerance. These Nazis broke the social contract of a pluralistic society so they’re no longer protected by the contract.
Removed by mod
You don’t have a first amendment right to have a University of Florida chapter of the College Republicans. The University does have the right to dissolve clubs and organizations associated with the school if they are engaged in any conduct it deems inappropriate.
Nah, taxpayer funded institutions shouldn’t just be able to say any group they don’t like is inappropriate and ban them with zero process and University students do have a first amendment right to assemble themselves
This Republican group should be banned because they’re a discriminatory group of bigots who make the environment unsafe for other students and violate civil rights laws, but what this dipshit university (which let this nazi club carry on for years until they made headlines and is actually now just trying to make a new college Republicans chapter, which is a whole other 1st amendment violation) thinks is “appropriate” should have absolutely nothing to do with it
The moment a group in some disrupts the student experience for others, the university has a right to ban them.
the university has a right
No, the university has an obligation to comply with laws that forbid groups that would try to disrupt some students’ experiences for bigoted reasons. They do not have the right to pick and choose when they honor that obligation.
Not sure where you got the picking and choosing idea from–that came out of thin air.
You have the right to remain silent but we’re still having this conversation because rights are something you get to choose when you exercise and when you waive. The university’s board of trustees or whatever governing entity they have should not get to choose, they should just be reading the law and following it to the best of their ability.
Oh. Thats a can of worms… By that logic, no university which recieves taxpayer money should not have the right to regulate speech on campus, which given how student loans and grants function, means all of them.
But these universities are private entities not government bodies, even ones closely associated with states like this one here, and should be allowed to remove groups like this for a wide range of reasons.
(IANAL), they should just air on the side of the parodox of tolerance and then not trust Florida to stick to it as its appeales get judge shopped around until someone gives the shoe leather sommelier what they want.
no university which recieves taxpayer money should not have the right
I think you probably mean
no university which receives taxpayer money should
nothave the rightor
noevery university which receives taxpayer money should not have the rightOnce we get grammar squared away, a social studies lesson on how laws like Title IX protections against sex discrimination have been enforced on colleges and universities for the last several decades is also in order
Won’t someone rid me of all of these mettlesome Nazis?
You’re thinking of “meddlesome”, as in meddle (interfere). “Mettlesome” means being characterized by mettle (courage).
How can you believe that you know someone else else’s thoughts without blowing your own head off?
I assumed you weren’t calling Nazis courageous. Was I wrong?
Of course you were wrong. Apparently, you have more holes in your head than most humans
So you are saying these Nazis are courageous. In that case you’re just a piece of shit. My mistake.
Are you on shrooms or acid? Cause I definitely never said that.
What the fuck is wrong with you?
Cause I definitely never said that.
You called Nazis “mettlesome.” As another user pointed out, mettlesome means characterized by courage. Rather than just saying “ah, my mistake I must’ve meant meddlesome like you said” you had a weird crashout over being corrected that included you saying someone was wrong to assume you weren’t calling Nazis courageous.
So not only did you technically say it from the get-go, you then doubled down later on. You said it twice in two different ways.
I said:
I assumed you weren’t calling Nazis courageous. Was I wrong?
You replied:
Of course you were wrong
Dunno how else to interpret that.
deleted by creator
Because of course they do.
Removed by mod
So yelling “FIRE” in a theater is ok?
Telling their only problem with the nazi salutes is the anti salmonism. As if they were the only victims.
Gross comment
Gross to not deny communists, socialists, leftists, trade unionists, opposition politicians, gypsies, slavs, gays, and others dying en masse at the hands of the Nazis and only recognize the suffering of the one group that is now itself being claimed to be represented by Nazis, which is to say the Israelis that claim the mantle of judism to deflect criticism from their naziism against other others.
Your comment is gross. In defense of fascists pursuing a final solution against 5 million people, and multiple wars, just to start.
When you don’t understand basic English, perhaps you should shut the fuck up.
Nothing I said was incorrect, or immoral, but what you are defending is unconscionable, so you should be the one to shut the fuck up because you can’t fucking read. A dozen halfwits notwithstanding.
