Aldnoah. Zero is the most disappointing thing since my birth. Iām surprised thereās barely anyone who trashed this anime to death already, but Iām here to perform the task. Because I DO NOT LIKE THIS ANIME, I barely like it ironically. This isnāt a guilty pleasure anime, cuz I donāt feel any pleasure anytime I watch or think about it, only guilt. You have to be gullible to think this anime is good. I know this, because I was gullible. I remember watching this during middle school when I just started to watch anime, and I was pretty invested to some degree. Militaristic Mecha fighting alien Mecha, that concept alone interested my newbie weeb brain. And I love Mecha bro, Iāve loved it way before I began watching anime. And then High School came around and Darling in the Franxx became popular, instantly making this anime obsolete as A-1ās best Mecha (keep in mind: this was way before 86 came out). And once I rewatched Aldnoah, I was like āJesus Christ, WHAT DID I LIKE ABOUT THIS ANIMEā. Thatās when I realized I didnāt really liked this anime, that itās dumb and itās filled shit I donāt like. Once my generation realized this, there was peace in the Mecha community for a brief time as we were enjoying new Mecha shows. There was no more war, we as a community have moved beyond this anime, we solved the gunpla shortage, everything was at peace. And then Darling in the Franxx ended in a not so good way.
AND NOW, YOU PEOPLE ARE CALLING AD GOOD? WHEN THE FUCK DID WE GO BACK TO THIS? Iāve seen so many people unironically defend this anime and shit on other anime like Ren-a-Girlfriend, even though it has the same problems, anime with bad writing and worse characters. But people say Aldnoah.Zero is redeemed, because itās better than Darling in the Franxx. Now 1st of all, Darling in the Franxx aināt even that bad. I donāt love everything about it, but I canāt legitimately call it a bad anime. I have full respect for Mecha fans who hate Aldnoah and Darling, thatās completely understandable. What hurts me is when people say DitF is bad, and AD isnāt. And before you say āat least itās a realistic view of the Mecha genreā, Iāll say āWHO THE FUCK SAYS THATā. Being realistic isnāt enough to be good, and besides, an anime can be unrealistic and be really good. Gurren Lagann has nothing realistic about it and yet itās the best anime out there, everyone loves it. Aldnoah.Zero is a realistic look between real and super robot, yes. But itās not done well at all. If you think Iām gonna be praising these 2 short seasons, then Iām sorry, you people donāt know me very well. Maybe we can be friends in another lifetime. Cuz now, imma take this anime down a peg, cuz I hate them and when people donāt agree with me I get uncomfortable.
But before I tear this anime apart, I might as well talk about the stuff I do like. Itās not the worst anime ever so it gotta have some redeeming qualities, right? (*Letās see*, I like the music a lot). Side note: everything positive Iām gonna say has a huge ābutā in the end
- I wanna say both the character and mechanical designs are really good. A-1 Pictures has a lot of anime with good character designs and this anime is no exception. Masako really designed these characters very well. However, none of that matters if we arenāt invested in the characters. Keiji Teraoka worked on Gundam 00 before this, so the designs of the Sleipniers are really good. But that doesnāt apply to the designs of the Martian Kataphrakts. And the 3-D animation doesnāt do it any favors
- The voice acting is not bad. They got A-listers like Christina Vee, Patrick Seitz, Matthew Mercer, and best boy Bryce Papenbrook to voice these characters. But the acting can only get your so far with a poor script
- The start of the 2nd episode and the fight scenes are the only time I donāt feel like Iām in a death like coma. But it start falling apart what I start realizing that I donāt really care about whatās going on
- I do like this arc of Marito dealing with PTSD from the start of war. Itās a good arc that deals with something that not alot of real mecha touched upon. It just sucks that it doesnāt really get resolved. Heās probably one of my only characters I actually liked in this anime, along with Calm and maybe Magbaredge.
- Speaking of Calm, thereās this piece of dialogue I really do like. While watching everyone train in their Kataphrakts, Calm is so eager to become an official pilot. And then Yuuki tells him āYou have to remember that this is a warā. Itās a simple and fitting way for her to tell him to be careful what he wishes for, while reminding us of the brutal situation at hand. And thatās the last time Iām gonna say anything positive about the characters, so enjoy it
- But by far, the best thing about this anime is the music. The Hiroyuki Sawano original score is always on point, I just canāt hate it. I want to believe that good olā Hiroyuki San saw this anime and went like āalright I gotta fix this somehowā. Sawano just knows how to make epic soundtracks for any Mecha anime.
And thatās it for praise, this anime fails at every single level of storytelling. It just goes downhill from here. However, Iām gonna use a bunch of Mecha anime (mainly Gundam) and even SAO as a comparison (youāll find out why soon.)
Season 1:
- Plot:
You know how a variety Mecha (or just any anime in general) explains their world in the 1st 2 minutes of the anime? With the OG Gundam it explains what started the One Year War, Sword Art Online showed us a kid entering the Virtual world, Code Geass explains how Britainia took over Japan, etc. It tells us everything we need to know about the world we are about to enter. And how does Aldnoah start? I guy talking about Earth to a blonde lady and then it pans out to a spaceship with no explanation. This sets the tone of the anime, ITāS FUCKING UNINVESTING. It doesnāt give us a reason to get invested in this world or its characters who we just met. We donāt even know whatās going on until later in the episode when weāre given some lazy exposition.
As for the plot itself, Iām gonna be honest, I never knew the plot of the anime. Sure, you can just say āitās just about people fighting aliens in giant robotsā', but Iām pretty sure thereās a better way to explain it. So what I got, is after a planned assassination towards the Princess of the Vers, Asseylum Vers Allusia, the Vers Martian Empire uses this as an excuse to launch a full on tantrum on Earth and our cardboard standees have to fight to survive. Now the 1st question on my mind is, why does Mars want to attack Earth? Well I hope youāre ready to die with that question in mind, because this anime is gonna answer that question for you. None of the Martians ever give a solid reason why they hate humans so much or why they need to conquer Earth. Theyāre just mindlessly evil, and itās ok for an anime to have the usual hammy mustache twirling villain, especially in Mecha. But this is an anime thatās trying to be as serious as other real mecha that came before, that had way more compelling villains with understandable motivations. Take Zeon for example from Gundam, theyāre going to war with the Earth Federation for independence for the space colonies. They may have done some fucked up shit, but at least you understand their reasoning. But in this anime, thereās no solid reason as to why theyāre doing this. Sure, they say that they want Earthās resources, however none of us ever get a sense of why they need it. We donāt see any other Martians suffering without those resources or even see them hating Earth that much. Thereās more that sucks about the Martians, but Iāll save that for later along with how most of the human characters arenāt that good either.
But for now, letās the concept of Militaristic Mecha forced to fight Super Mecha. Itās a cool concept on paper, but I feel this anime doesnāt pull it off as well as it couldāve. The 1st few minutes of the 2nd episode really did a good job as establishing the Martians as a threat and the fights are strategically well planned out. But the more I think about it, the 1st 2 Kataphraks would have easily been dealt with in another way, and Iāll get to that later. But ya, I found the plot held back by the really poor writing.
- Characters:
Iām starting off with the main character himself, Inaho Kaisaka. And I have something to say, whenever people call Kirito a boring character, remember that Inaho exists. He only has one facial expression, and it never changes. At least Kirito shows emotions throughout SAO and actually has interests in the series. What does Inaho have that shows he has human emotions? Even when his fucking friend dies RIGHT IN FRONT OF HIM, he keeps a straight face during and after his death. If that doesnāt cement how emotionless he is, then I donāt know what will. He doesnāt care about his sister, his friends, hell, it doesnāt even look like he even cares about the war going on. I donāt mind stoic protagonists, I just stated that Kirito is fine, as he still has moments where he cares about the people and the world around him in both the virtual world and real world. But this isnāt the case for Inaho, he just has zero emotions.
And I havenāt even gotten to the rest of the Terrain characters. Outside of Marito and Calm, who wouldāve worked as great characters if they were better used in a better anime, the majority of the characters have barely any chemistry with each other. Zero, I mean no chemistry. We donāt care about these characters and weāre supposed to be rooting for them to survive. They only exist to tell us about whatās going on in the war and how powerful the Martians are. They donāt talk about how they feel or how much this war is taking a mental toll on them.
I think thatās why Marito and Calm are the only characters I thought had potential. Marito has experience fighting the Martian and has trauma from it, so it wouldāve been interesting if heās forced to confront his past. As Calm, heās the only one who shows actual hate towards the Martians and unlike the Martians (who only hate Terrains because theyāre told to), he has actual reasons why. His home was destroyed and his best friend was killed by the Martians, so itās more understandable. So it wouldāve been interesting if he found out if the Princess was alive and learns to let go of his hate. I honestly think that Marito and Calm shouldāve been the main characters instead of Inaho, and have this mentor and student dynamic where they learn from one another. Magbaredge is another character who I thought wouldāve been cool if she was given more to do. She couldāve been like Sumeragi from Gundam 00, where sheās fighting against her past demons, or in this case Maritoās. She reveals that sheās the sister of the soldier that Marito forcibly killed. This couldāve been a really good arc where Magbaredge learns to forgive Marito.
And then we have the Martians, both good and bad. Letās go with good Martians, Slaine Troyard and Princess Asseylum. With them being the 1st characters to appear 1st in the series, youāll think that the anime would focus on giving them some interesting traits to make us invested in them. And yet, none have any traits that make them interesting. And I know that people say that Slaine is the only good character, but only because he has an actual motivation to save the princess. Outside of that, all he does is do what his bosses tell him to do while being abused by him. The moment when he helped Inaho fight against one of the Martians, I thought he wouldāve joined them to take on the landing castle. But no, he gets shot down, tortured by his abusive boss, gets saved by Sazbone, and joins him for no reason. And he doesnāt get any better as we see in season 2. And trust me, Iāll get to that soon, VERY SOON.
But now letās move onto the next āgoodā Martian, Princess Asseylum Vers Allusia. But before that, thereās something I want to say, her loli maid, Eddeolrittuo, is the most annoying character in the anime and doesnāt need to exist. But on to Asseylum, and as a princess character, I think she is probably the worst one Iāve seen so far. Sheās so gullible and arrogant, that itās so unbearable. After seeing Martians more than willing to kill humans and seeing that her OWN PEOPLE wanted her dead, she still thinks that thereās still a chance for people to get along with the people of Earth. To the point where she makes a really dumb decision that leads to the last safe place on Earth to be attacked and destroyed. Also, they forced her in this love triangle between Inaho and Slaine, but not only it doesnāt work, but it also becomes meaningless in season 2 (trust me, season 2 fucks up a lot of shit).
Before I move on, I want to bring up Kudelia from Iron Blooded Orphans for comparison. She starts off similarly to Asseylum in the beginning of the anime, where she thinks that once she gives her speech, everything will be better. But thereās one major difference, Kudelia eventually learns that not only people from Mars are suffering, but also people around space are suffering as well. She finally gets shit done and calls out Gjallarhorn for the shady shit theyāve been doing. If Asseylum had a similar arc, she wouldāve been a way better character.
Now onto the bad guys, and all you need to know is that they hate Terrains. Thatās it, thatās their only personality trait and we donāt learn anything else about them. They are just cartoonishly evil, to the point where we canāt even view them as actual villains. To the point where the Orbital Knights were forgettable, to the point where their mecha are the only memorable thing about them. Count Cruhteo and Lord Saazbaum are the only recurring villains and they arenāt that different, with Cruhteo being a slight but not so good exception. Sure, he tries to help the princess eventually, But that was after he constantly abused Slaine, dropped his landing castle onto Japan, and tortured him for info. So it was not only very rushed, but also some wasted potential. He shouldāve been someone who grew to see how immoral Martianās invasion is and how he grew to see both Terrains & Martians as similar. And then thereās Lord Saazbaum, where they tried and failed to make his motivations understandable. He shows Slaine this PowerPoint of Martians hating Earth, while giving exposition explaining how Earth wonāt share their resources. This honestly feels kinda weak, because we donāt see any of the Terrains rejecting them. I also found his other reasoning for hating Earth really dumb. His girlfriend dies while on a mission and now he blames Terrains for it. And want to know how she dies? Because the portal on the moon blows up and the falling debris kills her. If one of the Earth soldiers actually got a shot off of her, then I wouldāve bought it. But her death was caused because of the arrogance of the Martians thinking their hot shit. Saazbaum shouldāve been mad at the Vers for sending them on this mission. And he doesnāt become any more interesting as the series goes on.
So ya, the cast of characters on both the good and bad side really drags this anime down. They donāt develop at all and donāt have anything interesting about them. If they were given any motivations, arcs, or personalities, we might have cared a little more. But no, these characters are very forgettable. It would be funny if it werenāt so sad.
- World Building:
With it being a Mecha anime, youāll think the world building would be interesting, right? Unfortunately, itās handled pretty poorly. Thereās so much shit that doesnāt make any sense. Like the assassination itself. For starters, why didnāt they just plant a bomb under the limo instead of putting a rocket launcher into a public parking lot? That place was very conspicuous and couldāve been easily witnessed by anyone. Also out of the multiple soldiers with guns, none of them bothered intercepting those missiles. And trust me, this is only scratching the surface. Now letās talk about how the United Forces of Earth (UFE for short) handles the threat. When it comes to the Martian Kataphraks, I understand why they have a hard time dealing with them. They have far more advanced Mecha and have plenty of time for preparation, that I understand. What I donāt understand is why they didnāt counter the missiles while they were in the air. They couldāve prevented severe damage to their communication systems , especially since they already had jets in the air.
Another thing that bugged me was the Aldnoah Drives themselves, since weāre never explained how they work. All we know is that only people with the Vers bloodline, along with the Orbital Knights who swore their devotion to them. But, how exactly does that work? Especially since Slaineās dad was the one who made them. So why would he make it so only one person and his family can use it? Overall, thereās so much that doesnāt make any sense in the world, to the point where I canāt even get invested. Maybe Iām missing something, feel free to call me out for it (just be civil about it)
- Mecha:
As I said before, the Mecha designs on the Terrain Kataphrakts are pretty good. The Sleipniers and Areions do look practical and militaristic, I can definitely see these 2 being used in real life combat. However, I do wish their load out is a bit better. They do have assault rifles (with a grenade launcher), sniper rifles, a pistol, and knife, which aināt bad. But it wouldnāt hurt to have a bazooka and a heated melee weapon. It wouldāve also been cool if they had different types of Sleipniers and Areions (like a sniper type, cannon type, melee type, etc.). I donāt know, thatās something Iāve always liked about Mecha, they have a variety of Mecha types for multiple situations. Take Gundamās GMsĀ for example, they have a variety of types; thereās the GM Sniper, GM Cannon, GM Striker, GM Night Seeker, etc. Each of them are made with a specific role and use specific weapons to achieve their missions. But thatās just a suggestion, I still like their designs.
As for the Martian Kataphraks, I canāt really say the same thing. They look weird, and not in a villainous way. The Electris looks like a Gau (a Zeonic carrier) with arms and legs, the Argyle looks like white fat duke, and the Hellas is a metal octopus. Although I do like the idea of real mecha fighting these super Mecha with Strategic planning, I found that these fights couldāve been easily solved. The Electris may have a barrier that absorbs everything, but if it trips itāll sink into any surface. The Argyle literally only has one melee weapon, so you couldāve handled it with long ranged attacks. The only ones I thought were cool were the Dioscuria and the Tharsis. They actually do look like a threat and are designed pretty well. The Dioscuria looks like the final boss, with the abilities of the 1st 3 Kataphrakts. But those long fingers are a bit too much. And although the Tharsis looks like itās gonna help the Terrains, it barely does anything on screen. It only charges Into the fight at the last minute, and thatās it.
There are more of them, but they only appear for one second each and never again until season 2. The mechanical designs (at least on the Terrianās side) arenāt half bad, but the one thing that kinda ruins it is the 3-D animation. They really do look out of place with the 2-D animation and donāt move that smoothly. A-1 Pictures obviously didnāt realize that Mecha can always be 2-D animated too. So overall, I would like to say the Kataphrakts are the saving grace of the anime, but would honestly be lying. If they were animated better and were designed differently (with the exception of the Sleipniers and Areions), maybe that wouldnāt be the case.
- Vertic: The 1st season was a very rocky start. There was so much holding it back to the point where I think that it wouldāve been better if they went back to the ideas board and looked over what they couldāve changed. The right ingredients were there, good Mecha designers, good actors, a great concept on paper, but the series was plagued with bad writing, an uninteresting plot, and characters we donāt care about, this lead to an anime that will only be remembered as a massive disappointment. And it doesnāt get any better. Back when I saw the last episode for the 1st time, I thought a 2nd season wouldāve been great. That it couldāve wrapped up everything in a perfect bow. And couldnāt be more wrong in my entire life
Season 2: I think season 2 is probably the worst Mecha anime Iāve seen. Thereās so much wrong with this anime, to the point where it makes the last one look worse. Thereās barely anything redeemable about it, and Iāll tell you why
- Plot:
Itās literally the same plot as the last season. Martians bad, Earth good, they fight. But one slight difference is that now Slaine is now the leader and Princess Asseylum is now siding with them. Now first of all, those 2 differences are going to be the key difference of why this anime straight up sucks, but Iāll get to that later. But all I can say is that this anime tries nothing new. Thatās the best I can put it. Even the 1st few minutes of the anime is a recap of what happened in the last episode. So thereās barely a plot, believe me when I say that this isnāt even the worst of it
- Characters: Now this is where the true rotten meat of this shit show comes. Because MY GOD, these characters take character assassination and under development to the next level.
Now letās start off with the man himself, Slaine Troyard. And saying his character change from hero to villain came out of nowhere like saying the change from Zetaās dark tone to ZZās goofy tone came out of nowhere. Because his change in personality makes no Goddamn sense. To give you some form of context, in the last episode after Saazbaum shot Asseylum, Slaine then shot him multiple times and then shot Inaho for trying to reach the princess. And after that he took Saazbaum back into space. Let me remind you, he dedicated his life to protecting her and even killed one of the Orbital Knights after one of them revealed he wanted to kill her. So his switch to the dark side is just absurd. And yes, you can make the argument that he did that to save her life with Martian medical equipment, but that doesnāt matter since he goes behind her back towards the end.
Speaking of bitch, letās talk about the āPrincessā. Sheās a fake. Sheās actually Asseylumās sister, Lemrina Vers Envers. Now 1st of all, when did Asseylum ever mention that she ever had a sister? Sure sheās her half sister, but she never even mentioned she had any siblings in this damn anime. So whatās her Half sisterās motivations? Well I canāt tell you, because I donāt know. She basically exists to take Asseylumās place and thatās it. Itās basically like what they did in Gundam SEED Destiny with Meer pretending to be Lacus. But that anime at least gave her some motivation as to why she wants to be Lacus. Here, we barely get anything from Lemrina. All we know is that she barely interacted with her sister when they were little and they have different mothers. She also introduces a plot hole in the story, but Iāll get to that later.
Now letās talk about Lord Saazbaum, thereās not a lot to talk about. Especially since he gets kicked out of the story 3 episodes in. How, you may ask? Slaine backstabbed him after a battle between him and Inaho. Ok, he really shouldāve seen this coming. Especially after shooting the princess right in front of Slaine. Speaking of wasting, the new cast of Martian characters suck. None of them are memorable in the slightest. Half of them exist to give Slaine a hard time while the other either support him or the real princess. I should probably get to her too, right?
Well sheās literally in a coma for half the season. And once she wakes up, she escapes the moon, has a chat with her grandpa, and marries some random dude we barely met or cared about. If you didnāt like her in the last season, you definitely wonāt in this season.
Now letās go to Terrains characters, theyāre not as bad as the Martians, but they arenāt much better either. Inaho Kaizuka is as much of a machine as he was in season 1, especially with him becoming a Cyborg with his robotic eye. And although I keep complaining about Inaho being boring, I honestly thought this couldāve been a good way to show his descent into him giving into the war. Let me explain, if he started the series with some form of human emotion and progressively show less and less emotions, this couldāve easily been a great example of the war taking his humanity away. But I digress, letās get back to another problem with Inaho, his rivalry with Slaine Troyard. This is probably the worst rivalry Iāve seen in any anime Iāve seen for one reason, thereās not a connection to make them rivals. They barely interacted with each other in season 1 outside of them teaming up with each other to fight a Kataphrak and when Slaine shot Inaho. The only thing they have in common is that theyāre from Earth and they like Asseylum, which isnāt enough to make an investing rivalry. Letās talk about Lelouch and Suzakuās rivalry really quickly. Both were once friends and now theyāre fighting each for similar reasons. Lelouch is fighting his family & people for revenge while Suzaku is fighting his people for peace within both the Japanese and Britainians. Both have different and conflicting goals, but are fighting in a similar situation from one another. Itās called a juxtaposition, which a rivalry heavily depends on. Without this, Inaho and Slaineās rivalry feels very weak and uninteresting. Since neither of them have conflicting goals that we agree with, differing personalities that we find appealing, or tragedies we can sympathize with.
As for the other characters on the Terrain side, theyāre just as boring and forgettable as the last season. They barely do anything significant enough to affect the plot. Not even Calm has anything to do. However, I do like how Marito gets more involved in the fights and even manages to score some kills on some Martians. But I find his relationship with Magbaredge kinda weird. Like, last season, it was revealed that sheās the sister of the man Marito killed. And Now theyāre cool with each other? When did they work things out, especially since Magbaredge never brought up her brother in the whole season. These 2 shouldāve had an arc where they worked out this drama and maybe have some form of romance, especially since Magbaredge always uses the line, āyou know why you have trouble finding a dateā. Or maybe not, I donāt know. Moving on to another character whoās not used poorly, Rayet. Like the last season, sheās supposed to be a Martian who works with the Terrains, and yet it doesnāt work well. Especially in this season with her hating herself for being a Martian, and weāre supposed to care. And it really doesnāt work. And itās not just her, basically everyone else on the Terrain side has nothing to do.
So overall, the characters on both sides are either unchanged for worse, bastardized, or forgotten about. So both the plot and characters sucks shit, and I havenāt gotten to the worst part.
- World building (Plot Holes):
For being the second season, you expect them to at least expand on the world. And it doesā¦ā¦ And make a lot of plot holes in the meantime. If you thought the plot holes were bad in season 1, it has nothing on season 2. So letās start with the most glaring plot hole, how both Inaho and Asseylum survive getting shot in the head. Believe when I say, this makes Kira Yamatoās survival in a FUCKING NUKE look more realistic than this. I may be a mad man for saying that, but Iāll stand by it. But thatās not the worst of it, the next worst plot hole is that both sides have a military base on the moon. WHEN THE FUCK DID THEY HAVE MOON BASES? Both sides couldāve used the extra resources during the war. And sure you may say, āthey couldāve built it during the 16 months between season 1 & 2ā. I donāt need to be an engineer to tell you that 16 months isnāt nearly enough to build a space station on the broken moon. Especially with the situation both of them are in.
And oh wait thereās more, apparently thereās another thing that doesnāt make any sense. You wanna know how Lemira passes herself off as Asseylum you may ask? By shapeshifting herself as her sister herself. Now this is writing 101, but how the fuck can they do that? Is it like Aldnoah, and itās an ability that only the royal bloodline? Can all Martians do it too? This is something that was also presented in season 1, but I thought that Princess Asseylum only had this ability. But once I saw Lemira turn into Asseylum and Asseylum turning into her, thatās when I began to ask questions. Like was killing the Princess even necessary if you have someone who can disguise as her and make the Martians think the Terrains tried to hurt? Or is attacking Earth even necessary when you disguise yourself and invade it secretly via Marvelās Secret Invasion? But thatās all the plot holes I wanted to point out, the rest of the world building aināt worth remembering.
- Mecha:
I will say this, Mecha designs are pretty good (if you ignore the CGI animation). I do like the new variants of the Sleipniers and Areions for space, but I wouldāve liked it if it had a booster instead of grappling hooks. However, with the amount of debris in space it makes a bit of sense. I also like the Martian Kataphrakts here a lot more than season 1, since theyāre better designed, more of an actual threat, and made the fight scenes more creative.
However, I find it weird that the other Martians use these octopus looking fighter ships instead of mass produced Kataphraks. Thatās another thing I never understood, you have a handful of powerful Mecha and yet never attempted to make a Kataphrak easy to use by regular Martians. Thereās that cloning Kataphrak, but that is not really the same.
And the final battle between Inahoās Sleipnier and Slaineās Tharsis was probably the best fight scene in the whole series. If I just shut my brain off and pretend itās a short Mecha film, itās actually pretty good. However I like this fight until the ending, when Iām reminded that this is a bad anime. Because Inaho tries to save Slaine when they try to re-enter the atmosphere, and the anime cuts the whole thing with Inaho just straight up arresting Slaine. Ok, thatās my opinion on the Mecha designs and fights, now letās shit on the ending.
- Vertic: Before I end this massive tangent of this anime, letās talk about how the ending is. And letās just say, it makes Darling in Franxxās ending look like a masterpiece. So after Slaine gets arrested, the war just ends, Earth has an Aldnoah Drive, our side characters go back to their usual lives, and Asseylum marries a guy who we know nothing about. And the cherry on top of this shit show, Inaho literally just visited Slanie just to say that he just saved him because Asseylum told him to. A reminder that Inaho never developed as a character. Ya, from lazy writing to really poor characters, season 2 is the worst Mecha anime Iāve seen.
Finally thoughts: I think the worst thing about this anime (as you can probably tell from this review) is that it tries to be like a variety of mecha anime without understanding why theyāre good. It tries to be like the original Gundam series with the villains but not giving them compelling motivations, It tries to be like Gundam 00 with the real mecha vs super mecha fight but not balancing both sides, and it tries to be like Gundam SEED & Code Geass with the princess & rival thing but not making their princess likable or giving the rivals compelling character traits. It fails at everything that made the aforementioned Mecha special. Did no one on the writing team ever think that any of this would be better if they tweaked it a bit and wrote it in a more compelling way. At this point I just doubt that anyone on the development team actually gave a shit. So the anime is over now and I feel dead inside. It baffles me that people watch this anime and think itās good, because Iām not kidding when I say I hope I go the rest of my life without ever watching this anime again. I hate it. I would rather watch Sword Art Online (an anime that actually gets better over time despite itās faults) over this garbage any day of the fucking week. If you think that Iām a contrarian for saying that, then fine. Because outside of the music and the Mecha fight scenes, this anime falls flat in every single way in writing in the most noticeable way possible, which is why I donāt like it. If you actually like this anime and think Iām dumb for say all of this, feel free to argue youāre piece in a civilized way.
Season 1 was enjoyable to me, season two I couldnāt even finish one episode. It was immediately clear that the writing quality took a dive
Holy moly, thatās a long wall of text. Barely read a quarter of it. But yeah, aldonoah. Zero is such a piece of shit. Never liked it. I watched it right after watching Darling in the Franxx, and even then my teenager brain didnāt like it. First season was okish, second one? Absolute trash
Thank god 86 (peak) exists now.
I liked the first season because the protagonist actually used his brain, made observations, and came up with sensible plans. That was pretty refreshing; usually even āsmartā protagonists will come up with bullshit plans out of nowhere.
Then in season two he became an idiot and the show itself became amazingly stupid.
The 1st season was actually OK. Basically gundam but your protag uses a zaku and uses scientific reasoning and well-thought out tactics to defeat opponents. Of course the soundtrack is amazing.
And thatās where I end my compliments end. Now what about your opinions on Knights of Sidonia.
now I kinda want to see it. I consider tent a girlfriend bad anime but anime is like sex to me. there is tons a media I would not choose over bad anime.
That . . . is a lot more effort and emotion than I would expend on what I vaguely remember as being a mediocre mecha show. I just dumped it in the same mental category as Valvrave, Majestic Prince, and a bunch of other shows so undistinguished I donāt even remember what they were called, and largely forgot about it.



