Cimbazarov [none/use name]

  • 3 Posts
  • 432 Comments
Joined 4 months ago
cake
Cake day: December 27th, 2024

help-circle


  • "You can’t be putting your hope on China to save us, we have to save ourselves”

    I think the greater emphasis is on the fact that China is not going to save us. If we are going to be saved, it will have to come from ourselves. Maybe its improbable we are going to be saved at all.

    Saying we need an American Che is "great man of history"ing Che and the Cuban Revolution. In the past I said “we need an American Lenin” because I thought there isn’t any intellectual figure that can lead a party or revolution in the US. Im also probably wrong in stating that we “need an American Lenin”, and what we actually “need” is a theoretical understanding of how revolution can move forward in the US because that I don’t see. I don’t see a mass workers movement happening because the working class is just in disarray. It feels like we are in much different times than 1917 and even during the rise of fascism where there were semblances of class solidarity.

    What shape would a revolution in the US take today?


  • I followed some of it (regrettably) and I think it’s pretty clear Ethan is acting in bad faith and has no intention of changing his mind. I think Hasan also knows this and was using the debate to try to reach to his audience, but from what I’ve watched I’m pretty sure any Ethan viewer is already set in their ways and will just project whatever they already believe in on the debate. They’re also dumb so they probably think Ethan’s gotchas owned Hasan, cause they don’t understand anything besides drama and normalize Islamophobia so they can’t even identify it.

    The best thing Hasan could do was just ignore him, becuase he was crashing out on his own and was heading to irrelevancy. The debate put him back to relevancy while doing nothing for the causes Hasan is supposed to care about.

    Anyways, I wish I could forget these people exist because internet drama is so pointless
















  • I agree with him on Canada and France (I don’t really know enough about Australia). This Canadian election only postponed the conservatives winning the next one and doing shock-therapy style economics. France is looking to go the same way.

    It’s unfortunate that it feels like actual leftist options are out of the mainstream in elections and people don’t even know it because they think people like Macron and Carney are leftists (or anti-fascists) which is just wrong. It does feel like the centrists are stuck in the old word order where you follow free market doctrine and hope that exploitation of the third world bails you out. That and they continue being dogs for the US, but they obviously don’t like Trump and yet this is not enough for them to peel away from the US (I guess cause they still think he is just a phase and they can work with the next democrat president?).

    The centrists ability to not do anything but light neoliberalism makes fascism in these countries inevitable, especially when they get their power from being an alternative to the right and repress anything on the left.