FuckyWucky [none/use name]

Pro-stealing art without attribution

  • 858 Posts
  • 5.27K Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: March 21st, 2023

help-circle




  • Yep it creates a lot of bad incentives. For example, corps and individuals borrow in Euros or Dollars at 5-10% or whatever hoping the Central Bank will pick up the rest by maintaining crawling peg to help pay back the debt.

    When it turns out the central bank can’t and the exchange rate crashes, the debts become unservicable ie currency mismatch.

    So never raise rates to higher double digits especially when you have loose capital controls and fixed exchange rates.

    And the typical solution of “just lower rates” becomes more complicated too since private sector is still stuck with massive foreign currency debt even if Turkish central bank lower rates. And because a lot of Lira was created due to high rates which now flood the foreign exchange market.

    In case of Turkey, the >100% then 70-80% rates of the 2000s destroyed Lira credit market that makes it very difficult to switch back to low rates (that’s why Erdogans low rate experiment failed). In an economy with low stock of foreign currency debt, floating exchange rates, low interest rates wouldn’t cause runaway depreciation like what happened in Turkey.

    India is one of the few developing countries which has a low interest rate (5.25%), floating currency. And now they are planning some stupid nonsense like Dollar indexed Rupee bonds to curb depreciation (not even that high) which is happening due to a supply shock it has little control over.




  • Turkish Lira is absolutely cooked. They are drawing upon all their $ reserves to keep the Lira crawling peg stable. They’ll be forced to accelerate the crawl if they don’t want to go into foreign debt.

    Turkey and India are the two countries whose currencies are being cooked by this shock. Many commodity exporters including those in the AI supply chain are doing relatively fine because value of their exports rose quite a bit. But Turkey and India aren’t commodity exporters in the way Brazil is for example. There’s still a difference, India has minimal foreign currency debt, their interest rates are set fairly low. So, the Rupee will absorb most of it. Turkey depends on foreigners holding Lira for high interest rates (37% rate!), but when expected depreciation of Lira is higher than the interest, foreigners don’t want to hold it.