Little bit of everything!

Avid Swiftie (come join us at !taylorswift@poptalk.scrubbles.tech )

Gaming (Mass Effect, Witcher, and too much Satisfactory)

Sci-fi

I live for 90s TV sitcoms

  • 646 Posts
  • 10.4K Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 2nd, 2023

help-circle

  • My entire point as I’ve said over and over is that if you choose to pirate, go right ahead, but you can’t also call yourself a saint. If you need reasoning behind that then go ask the great philosophers, but that is where the moral compass sits.

    I personally think it’s all simply justification what you’re doing here, justifying that it’s still a good or bad thing.

    Humans are not good or bad. They are a grey maelstrom between. If you’re going to pirate, you should at minimum be decent enough to admit you’re doing an immoral thing but you choose to. You want proof it’s immoral? Well it’s sure as shit isn’t peachy white clean moral. Own up to it minimum.



  • As I said. People worked to make it. It doesn’t matter if you consider it stealing or not. It’s something that costs money and you did not pay for it. You are a viewer who did not pay for a ticket, or the disc, its one less in their metric, one less that did not count to the success.

    It doesn’t matter if it’s half the profit lost or one sale, it was something that you did not pay for and they did not get any credit for.

    You can justify however you want. You can try to spin that it’s better than giving them money, we can argue about the level of immorality until the cows come home.

    The fact is is that you still chose an immoral option. If you disagree with how their business is set up, you wouldn’t consume it at all.

    If a bake shop owner beats his staff who make minimum wage, you think it’s moral to go eat the bread because somehow you’re getting back at the owner? No. The moral option is not consume their bread at all.

    Again. You go do what you want, but you can’t claim to also be a saint while doing it. You can justify and justify, you’re still not paying for something.









  • No, it’s like saying don’t use nestle products at all if you want to claim to be moral.

    You’re arguing that you are moral by not paying for it while still chomping down on nestle chocolate. (And yes I know your follow up “but it’s still there I didn’t steal” that’s not the point)

    I’m saying you can pirate, but you can’t also claim to be moral while doing it because the only moral option is to not use it at all. Go ahead, do what you like, but by using it at all its immoral.

    The Baker baked the bread. If the baker is so evil and treats his workers so terribly, you aren’t exactly in the moral place by still eating his bread.