Blakey [he/him]

  • 26 Posts
  • 1.56K Comments
Joined 6 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 29th, 2020

help-circle




  • I don’t know what your criticism of identity politics looks like so I really can’t say. But I’m of the opinion that the problem with liberal idpol is the liberalism, not the idpol. Most often, in my experience, people who complain about idpol while talking about how the bourgeoisie use it to divide the proletariat are actually just part of that division. For example, it’s not BLM that divides the working class, it’s the racism that BLM is a response to. The kind of dickhead who complains that BLM is dividing the working class is just propagating that division, because BLM is in fact a response to real, material inequalities that are used to split the proletariat. If someone signals that they think BLM is in some way a waste of time, they are making it clear that black comrades aren’t safe around them, and therefore they are an impediment to class solidarity.

    I’m a white dude in my 40s and not terrifically well read so anyone who spots a problem with my position please by all means weigh in.



  • Punk, and other genres, are not purely about the technical aspects of the music. They are also about other things, including for example a fashion, and punk particularly has an accompanying ethos. You can buck that, push the boundaries of what’s considered punk, and if you keep the aesthetic you likely will be considered a heterodox punk… But punk is 100% political. It’s a subculture. It’s not just a purely musical category. Yeah the higher incidence of Nazi metal bands isn’t about the chord structure, that’s an argument AGAINST your point. There are more Nazi metal bands than Nazi smooth jazz bands because the metal subculture (well, certain parts of it) are more amenable to Nazi ideas. If musical genres were purely about the music itself you wouldn’t expect to see that phenomenon, it happens specifically because genres are bigger than that.




  • “identity politics and class politics” stands out, too. Dude the working class have identities that matter to us. The people from minority groups whose safety and material interests you deride as “identity politics” are overwhelmingly working class. You know why African Americans scabbed at various times in the American labour movement? Yeah.