I suppose the words “assassinated” or “deposed” are too woke

  • AntifaSuperWombat [she/her]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    64
    ·
    3 days ago

    After the uprising was crushed by the Freikorps, a government-sponsored paramilitary group, Luxemburg and her comrade Karl Liebknecht were captured and killed.

    The murder of Rosa Luxemburg and Karl Liebknecht is just referred to as “captured and killed” blob-no-thoughts

    • Blakey [he/him]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      30
      ·
      3 days ago

      See, that’s how I think they should describe the killing of the Romanovs - captured, then killed to prevent them falling into the hands of the whites (and also acknowledge that Rosa and Karl were in fact murdered)

    • Blakey [he/him]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      35
      ·
      3 days ago

      I mean, Louis xvi was tried and convicted and his daughter released in exchange for french prisoners, it’s a pretty different scenario to the Romanovs being gunned down in a basement in a semi panic, against orders iirc, because the whites were approaching. I don’t think what happened to the Romanovs (understandable or not) qualifies as “execution”.

      • Feed_el_Castro [he/him, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        25
        ·
        3 days ago

        From Wikipedia article on “execution by firing squad”:

        Execution by firing squad, historically called fusillading (from the French fusil, rifle), is a method of capital punishment, particularly common in times of war

        From Wikipedia article on “murder”:

        Murder is the unlawful killing of another human without justification or valid excuse and committed with the necessary intent as defined by the law in a specific jurisdiction.

        Which one do you think applies more? By their own logic

        • Keld [he/him, any]@hexbear.net
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          20
          arrow-down
          1
          ·
          3 days ago

          Both? I mean more the second than the first tbh, given that they were also stabbed.

          The Romanvos were killed without any form of legal process as non combatants ad hoc by whatever tools were available at the time to kill them, by people who were not doing so dispassionately. The question of whether it is murder is not whether it is justified on a tactical basis (Which it absolutely wasn’t for the girls, it turned out it wasn’t for either Nicholas or Alexei, and I would argue the bolsheviks didn’t think that this branch of the Romanovs mattered right up until this killing and based on their actions subsequently thought as a collective that this wasn’t done right), it is a question of lawfulness, and the killing of the Romanovs was not based on any kind of lawful process. Had they tried Nicholas and sentenced him to death, that would be one thing, but they had no such trial, because no one gave a shit about Nicholas as a symbol by the time of the civil war. Not the reds, not the whites, not the greens, not the blacks, and if there were somehow blues too then they didn’t care either.

          The question is not whether they were murdered, they were, the question is why their murder matters more than thousands of others that Nicholas was responsible for. Why the first line of Nicholas’ biography isn’t “Emperor, Self Proclaimed Autocrat, and Murderer”. And on a broader scale, why we don’t, for instance, label colonial or imperialist violence as murder.

          • Feed_el_Castro [he/him, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            3
            ·
            edit-2
            3 days ago

            Fundamentally I don’t disagree with anything you’ve said. But, as you make clear in your last paragraph, there’s a very relevant propagandistic angle to all of this.

            First of all: I don’t agree that an execution is more legitimate because a guy who studied law and wears a wig says so. In the case of Nick, instead of a guy with a wig it was a decision by some form of Soviet power (whether Lenin directly, the representative of the workers, or a collective of communist party members, as it isn’t clear who made the decision). Is it less legal than the word of a judge? I disagree. Lenin also studied law BTW.

            And second of all, the propagandistic element: the word “execution” is a lot more neutral than the word “murder”. I genuinely don’t care that much about the definitions in this instance, I’ve already made it clear that popular power isn’t or shouldn’t be less legitimate than the word of a judge. It’s relevant how, propagandistically, Marie Antoinette being murdered in peace time out of bloodthirst in a public square is completely normal and accepted, and lil’Nick being hastefully executed as a panic response to a pro-Tsarist uprising is a heinous act of cold-blooded violence. The French will literally have Gojira perform during a representation of the beheading of Marie Antoinette as an opening of the Olympics and everyone in the west will cheer (myself included), but suddenly cry foul when it’s the Bolsheviks doing it to their own Tsar.

        • Blakey [he/him]@hexbear.net
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          18
          arrow-down
          1
          ·
          3 days ago

          My point is that I don’t think either applies. It wasn’t a judicial sentence, it wasn’t even a summary execution, because it wasn’t a punishment. It was done as a matter of practicality to prevent the tsar and his family falling into the hands of the Whites. The fact that under other circumstances Nicholas, at the very least, very likely would have been executed doesn’t really change that that isn’t what happened.

  • purpleworm [none/use name]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    51
    ·
    3 days ago

    Deposed is just being removed from the throne and assassinated implies he wasn’t in captivity already. I think simply “executed” is the most accurate, since I don’t think whatever laws would consider it a “murder” were really in effect by that point.

    • Blakey [he/him]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      26
      ·
      3 days ago

      I think you have to just use “killed”. Nicholas would likely have been executed if he survived the war, and I would shed no tears for that, but the children? They weren’t tried, convicted, and executed for their crimes, they were killed to prevent them from being retaken by the whites - even if execution were justified, they were killed for practical, not judicial, reasons.

      • purpleworm [none/use name]@hexbear.net
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        9
        ·
        3 days ago

        I was coming from the standpoint that they were held captive and killed by soldiers (against orders or not), which to my understanding is typically what “executed” means, but I guess if we are defining execution as necessarily punitive, then “killed” is the right word, though does that mean there isn’t a general term for killing captives?

        • Keld [he/him, any]@hexbear.net
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          8
          ·
          3 days ago

          Yes. Murder. Like I’m not trying to be glib here, but that is the word for killing captive non combatants without trial.

          But the word “Executed” is typically used about “Putting someone to death”, i.e. rendering someone dead who usually has no means of changing that outcome. But it doesn’t have to be a legal sentence.

  • Chana [none/use name]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    13
    ·
    3 days ago

    It was illegal to kill him, you see. This is a very important distinction to make, we must always frame actions in terms of early 20th century Russian imperial law.

    • AntifaSuperWombat [she/her]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      27
      ·
      3 days ago

      In the years following his death, Nicholas was reviled by Soviet historians and state propaganda as a “callous tyrant” who “persecuted his own people while sending countless soldiers to their deaths in pointless conflicts”. Despite being viewed more positively in recent years, the majority view among historians is that Nicholas was a well-intentioned yet poor ruler who proved incapable of handling the challenges facing his nation.[1][2][3] He and his family were canonised as passion bearers by the Russian Orthodox Church in 2000, following the discovery and reburial of their remains in 1998.

      and then down in the article just mentioned briefly:

      Leadership of the Russian Orthodox Church also condemned antisemitic pogroms. Appeals to the faithful condemning the pogroms were read publicly in all churches of Russia.[69] In private Nicholas expressed his admiration for the mobs, viewing antisemitism as a useful tool for unifying the people behind the government;[70] however in 1911, following the assassination of Pyotr Stolypin by the Jewish revolutionary Dmitry Bogrov, he approved of government efforts to prevent antisemitic pogroms.

      The well-intentioned Nazi mob supporter

      • Feed_el_Castro [he/him, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        21
        ·
        3 days ago

        the majority view among historians is that Nicholas was a well-intentioned yet poor ruler

        The “well-intentioned” ruler in question:

        Bloody Sunday, also known as Red Sunday, was the series of events on Sunday, 22 January [O.S. 9 January] 1905 in St Petersburg, Russia, when demonstrators, led by Father Georgy Gapon, were fired upon by soldiers of the Imperial Guard as they marched towards the Winter Palace to present a petition to Tsar Nicholas II.

        • stalin420 [he/him, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          13 hours ago

          Estimates of Nicholas II’s personal wealth have been exaggerated. As Emperor of All The Russias, and an autocrat, the resources under his command were virtually incalculable. However, the vast majority of this was owned by the state as crown property; the Romanov family’s personal wealth was only a fraction of this. As monarch, the income of Nicholas was 24 million gold roubles per annum: this derived from a yearly allowance from the treasury, and from the profits of crown farmland.[254] From this income, he had to fund staff, the upkeep of imperial palaces and imperial theatres, annuities for the royal family, pensions, bequests, and other outgoings. “Before the end of the year, the Tsar was usually penniless; sometimes he reached this embarrassing state by autumn”.

          Absolutely disgusting. They should shoot him again.

          • Feed_el_Castro [he/him, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            2
            ·
            11 hours ago

            Western “experts” writing about Stalin:

            Even if he pretended to have a very meagre lifestyle, always wearing the same coat and having a simple life, in reality he was the richest man in the universe because the entire state belonged to him, so he was, like, totally(tarianly) worse than our benevolent Bezos

            Western “experts” writing about Nick2:

            He may have seemed very rich, with his golden jewelry, his personal collection of art from all over the world, his plundered historical reliques from Egypt and the ancient world, and his constant banquets celebrated in his own palace and prepared by his thousands of servants. But this small bean was really a poor guy just like you and I, who didn’t make it to the end of the year with his teeny-weeny budget

      • Keld [he/him, any]@hexbear.net
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        14
        ·
        3 days ago

        He stated that they shouldn’t promulgate the protocols of the elders of zion because he didn’t want to poison the well of antisemitism. Which is just an incredible concept. Directly he said something to the effect of “You can’t fight for a good cause with dirty means” when he found out that the text was a forgery.

        There really aren’t word for how much Nicholas sucked

      • senseamidmadness@lemmygrad.ml
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        7
        ·
        3 days ago

        I dearly love it as it was a childhood favorite of mine, but it’s obvious as an adult that it is a monarchist propaganda piece. I think it’s redeemed because it clearly doesn’t take place in reality, due to, well, Rasputin being a spellcasting warlock who comes back from the dead with a talking sapient white bat as a companion/familiar.

        Interestingly enough there was a Broadway stage musical adaptation a few years ago which is more strongly an anti-Communist propaganda piece. It doesn’t feature Rasputin at all (the writers said in interviews “he was dead at the time we set this musical and we want it to be more realistic”) and instead has Anastasia being pursued all the way to Paris by a scary Bolshevik/KGB type guy who is trying to kill her. He’s even the son of one of the Romanov’s executioners so he feels he has to “finish the job.” Much more blatant in its propaganda.